There is a progression within the astral sorcery mod itself. txt) or read online for free. You only see them around Y level 4. But if those don't work, the industrial foregoing laser drill can make rock crystal ore that you just break with a pickaxe and get the rock crystals. even just chucking size 1 celestial crystals into the entire process can give your Size II, Focus I blah blah blah split those up to their. From Feed The Beast, Wiki Aevitas is a bright constellation added by Astral Witchcraft. Currently rock crystal ore will only replace basic smooth stone. When a crystal is at max size, it can still absorb starlight but instead of growing, it has a 1/6 chance to split into 2 crystals with lowered size. Also remember you can redo an astral cystal. 00:00 Celestial C. For the past 3 days, I've been trying to get Astral Sorcery to add rock crystals to other dimension (i. ago. These Astral Sorcery constellations need a Telescope or Observatory to find, and can only be found by attuned players. When placed in the world, it generates Starlight which can be used to power other blocks from the mod through the use of the Linking Tool. The stats only matter with the Astral and are random when it goes through the conversion process. Astral Sorcery offers a bunch of content in the Overworld, letting your explore both sky and ground to find ruins, new mineral, and new elements. Properties. 8. 106. TheLucksman • 5 yr. 16 :: E02 - Rock Crystals, L…225 Sooty Marble 12 Marble Pillars 4 Chiseled Marble Structure Recipe Starlight: 70% Starlight Crafting Altar 1 / 2 Astral Tome entry “ ” Crafting things with starlight and liquid. It is the fourth and last tier of crafting altar and is used throughout the Radiance chapter of the Astral Tome. We need to use a starmetal cutting tool to turn 1 crystal into 2 crystals. Then when you toss it into the liquid starlight there is a chance that it splits into two crystals. 32). Add a Comment. So, I'm playing Direwolf20 1. The rate at which growth occurs can be increased by shining starlight from a Collector Crystal or Celestial Collector Crystal on. The Ritual Pedestal is a block added by Astral Sorcery. Self-attunement is gated behind AS progression, and discovery of the Bright constellations. some time it can take 6 buckets of starlight to split a crystal, sometimes it only takes one (after it. I whacked away at one for a while before it disappeared for good. The Collector Crystal is a block added by Astral Sorcery. The lower the purity, the more likely you'll lose a lot of size due to whole portions of the crystal breaking off by accident when grinding. 2. Set eject, and it will mine and send stuff home. Results are largely dependent on the quality and coherency of the change made to the astral. Other particles from the mod show up, and the particle settings are set to all. A: Lash, you should play Sevtech nextLash: Why? A: Cause no one has finished it!Lash: That's not true, a lot of people have finished itA: You should play it. It is used in crafting recipes and can be ground into Stardust by using a Grindstone. pdf), Text File (. help automating celestial crystal growth from astral sorcery. The more opaque inclusions, the more light is lost when it. Fix was to quit out of the game, rename the astral sorcery folder in the save. It is used as a component in most of the mod's recipes and can be infused with Liquid Starlight via a Starlight Infuser to be converted into a Resonating Gem. toml file and edited the. I don't astral sorcery, but that seems like a very crappy crystal. To do this, you need to use the grindstone, take a. Collector crystals are the big one where having purity and cutting maxed gives you the. The bright constellations are able to be attuned. Edit. Main article: Stellar Refraction Table This constellation. Go find a large structure made of marble and dig under it and place a crafting table somewhere under the crystal you'll find there. So I want to automate feeding my lightwells with rock crystals. 4. Starmetal Ore is a block added by Astral Sorcery. murapix. Rock Crystal not splitting. The source code indicates mod integration for Astral Sorcery and an information provider for size and purity. Four ores are revealed in this Age: Iron, Gold, Lapis lazuli and Rock crystal ore. ago. Hi, I tried to get into Astral Sorcery and got stuck right away. Remove all the blocks and water directly above the collector crystal so it is open to the sky. 1 Types of constellations (before MC 1. The Astral Tome is a book added by Astral Sorcery. He also references a spreadsheet that details what traits you want for optimal use in various situations. In Minecraft Astral Summoning, the game’s main element is crystals; with them you can craft liquid axes, pickaxes, shovels, etc. New comments cannot be posted. It is similar in function to the Lens, but can redirect multiple beams from one prism. 9 Our First Rock Crystal. They spawn near bedrock, are really rare and get destroyed when harvested with any automated method. We will cover transmutations and starlight. Tool Efficiency, and Shape can at max stack to 4 (for swords that means you either go for 2+2 or 3 +1, any more it isnt counted unless you got a fixer upper ala Apotheosis but for Astral), Tool Durability and Size can stack to 9 (for axes and pick axes thats 3 crystals with max Tool Durability) Size gives you bonus Durability on top of Tool. Tried to find it. EDIT: The recipe for marble is 4 petrified resin, 4 petrified acorns, 1 bone meal. Floating Crystal inside of Ancient Shrine Floating crystals are naturally generated inside of various structures scattered across the world. The item you need is called Irradiant star. ~>Welcome rear amino users, I’m Gabu and dieser is Astral Sorcery with the chapter “Attunement”. The Altar works similarly to its predecessor the Luminous Crafting Table, and can make all recipes that the latter can. In Minecraft Astral Sorcery, the game’s main element is crystals; with them you can craft crystal axes, pickaxes, shovels, etc. It can contain more Starlight and adds 4 more slots for crafting. set sensor to detect fluid and wait until starlight is sucked up by the crystal. Rock Crystalが手に入ったらLightwell作ります. It gates access to certain things based on what different stuff you have done in the mod. Celestial crystals are enhanced versions of the regular rock crystals that can be mined deep underground. Bright constellations can be customized to. 4) Make the attunement altar. Handling Rock Crystals properly when trying to properly shape them and polish them is a bit of a tedious process. It can hold up to 24 (64 in 1. Repeat for each ore. Once you find the samples on the surface, turn on the chunk lines and find the middle of that chunk. ,Supposing you’re a fan from Thor with Danish history, you’ll get one toe from playing Astral Sorcery in Minecraft. Available on the Twitch/Curse Launcher. Astral Sorcery is a magical mod for Minecraft based on the night sky that helps you harness the power of Constellations to empower your weapons and armor and the world around you. You only see them around Y level 4. The Resonating Wand is an item added by Astral Sorcery. The other important setting to change is the Min and Max settings - 0 and 60 are the defaults, and this used to be OK, but the "bottom" of the world. To do that you need a linking tool, and a Collector Crystal. Set the ores out and use the linking tool on the crystal then an ore. It is used to redirect Starlight in the Starlight network. The Iridescent Altar is a block added by Astral Sorcery. As pointed out, to summarize, you're at the whim of the RNG gods for crystal splitting. Attuned Rock Crystal. Yes probably, I'll try breaking the cluster and see if it can grow after that. ago. I crafted a brand new sword and it also only had a damage modifier of 6. I think you are trying to Transmute the vanilla Iron ore to Starmetal if I'm reading this right. I found a shrine, placed down a table, the crystal is shining light on it, and the table is emitting particles and that's it. Joke reference aside, you start Astral Sorcery by finding a Collector Crystal in a world-gen temple (should be some kind of workaround added by the pack if temples are disabled). Using a pickaxe enchanted with Fortune will increase your yield substantially. so if you want "perfect" crystals you want to cycle through Astral crystals till you hit high 90's purity. These. r/feedthebeast. bak, relaunch. The crystal needs to be at full size. Today I tried experimenting with crystal tools from Astral Sorcery. So if I was to place them 12 away from each of the sides they would be sqrt (12x12+12x12)=16. Floating crystals are naturally generated inside of various structures scattered across the world. They spawn near bedrock, are really rare and get destroyed when harvested with any automated method. Had Sharpness VII on them so they were at 17. . They can hold a single item. . Hey guys, was wondering if rock crystal splitting from Astral Sorcery was disabled in this modpack. It is used to affect the area around it with the attuned Rock Crystal or Celestial Crystal. 6. When placed in the world, it generates Starlight which can be used to power other blocks from the mod through the use of the Linking Tool. Because quartz crystals can be found. You. It mods Minecraft 1. 1. This makes Astral Sorcery mid-game at best for me. You can increase size by throwing them into liquid starlight and cutting does not matter for rituals. 2566. Celestial Crystals at max power give off more than twice as much starlight as rock crystals. place liquid starlight. Find the first 5 constellation papers and put a crafting table near a Collector Crystal. [Astral Sorcery] Can attuned celestial rock crystals be duplicated? I'm pretty new to this mod, and since the manual is a bit cryptic I might not be doing things the right way. #4. Collector Crystals can be made by the player,from Rock Crystal. Make the wand from AS. It's a base 250 breaks (or maybe 200, it's been a. the result doesn't appear on the right side of the altar's ui. If a Rock Crystal, Celestial Crystal, Crystal Tool, or Mantle of Stars is thrown onto the main altar block a similar cutscene occurs and attunes the item to the Constellation. Pros: Can get star dust at least for the cost of some liquid. It can be created on the Luminous Crafting Table and higher, during times where the altar has a sufficient amount of starlight. The quarry has been running for some thing now and yet i did not find any rock crystal (so far 1 row of chunks in a 512x512 area). mistrb5000. Feeding Astral Sorcery Lightwells . It restarts your progress to 0, but keeps the level you were on, while giving you a new starting constellation (the one you used to craft it). It costs more resources though, but it is definitively an alternative. Welcome to the Astral Sorcery mod. When using a crafting table near one of the strange crystals in the ancient ruins, the crystal focuses a single ray of Starlight onto the table. Get one of your Rock Crystals and throw to in Liquid Spotlight together with Starmetal Dust. Astral Tome is the name of the source of most Astral Sorcery knowledge. Overcoming Random numbers - Darklands, Rock Crystal Gold, Celestial Altar starlight · Issue #2114 · DarkPacks/SevTech-Ages Still though the mod has an in-game book guide to help you get the ball rolling, you might still finds it difficult into build relevance of things while advancing in the mod’s lore. Crystals only become corrupted if you attuned it the 2nd time to alcara. It has to do with growth and life. Wenn you're a fan of Thor inside Norse mythology, you'll get a kick from playing Astral Sorcery in Minecraft. If broken prematurely it will only drop Stardust. 1 Collector Crystal;. If you're still struggling or have questions, I strongly recommend the Astral Sorcery Discord. These tools are vital to progress in the mod's lore. 12. Join. Hardness. Posting by u/Enzik - 33 votes and 11 comments2. PLEASE READ DESCRIPTION! LIKE/COMMENT/SUBSCRIBE! Twitch: Seed: . Check inside your playerdata folder in the world save for the astral sorcery folder. Cutting was reduced to 99, so to fix this, I put it on the grindstone. edit: someone said that you can make the tools with celestial crystals, so if you want the tools use them over normal ones. 2 modpack. It is found at extremely low altitudes, typically in a y-coordinate range of 1 to 6. 3) Link a collector crystal to the block with a linking tool. Some of its. It can be smelted into 1 Starmetal Ingot. • 4 yr. This is setup is my proof and function of the rock crystal splitting mechanic to make 100% pure crystals. [deleted] • 4 yr. It can be acquired by mining Rock Crystal Ore. I'm holding the resonating wand, which is supposed to show where the ore is, but I've traveled long distances, and even gone. It is the fourth and last tier of crafting altar and is used throughout the Radiance chapter of the Astral Tome. If placed within 16 blocks of another Collector Crystal, the. Astral Sorcery is a Game Mod for Minecraft themed around drawing power from the stars and constellations. 4 comments. The Medieval Age is the third Age encountered in the game. Blue Particles should emit. The Iridescent Altar is a block added by Astral Sorcery. The Luminous Crafting Table is a block added by Astral Sorcery. staging, which doesn't always follow the mod's progression in the book. e. I'm aware to make the cluster you need to have a single block pool of liquid starlight from a bucket, and I keep dropping the rock crystal. While they can be useful on their own, using several of them together and with Colored Lenses can cause some amazing effects! While it seems like crafting them might be fairly easy, there are a few things that are left out. If you attune a fresh crystal it's not supposed to be corrupt. In total the structure. A beam will come out of the Ritual. 16 AS changed rock crystals so that there is no "perfect" crystal that can be used for everything. Resonating Wand. One you get a celestial Crystal to 100% purity, you should use it as a seed for farming more, and then only use rock crystals when recipes don't allow celestial. How do you get perfect celestial crystals Astral sorcery? The Celestial Crystal can be acquired by mining a Celestial Crystal Cluster after it has fully developed. Gets to Starlight Infuser. It is used as a superior counterpart to Rock Crystals, and can reach a size of 900, which is 500 more than. • 5 yr. 4 comments. 2SevTech: Ages is a progression based modpack where you have to. Probably anything that generates ore will you get you that (orechid, lens of the miner, void miner) 7. It can be crafted from a Celestial Crystal that is attuned to any of the twelve bright or dim Constellations. The result is that finding crystals and areas with higher concentration of starlight is a challenge by itself. I used the rftools builder. - equal operator: list length == 0/1/2 (as needed) (or != or >0) - You can place all but the last into a variable store. Alternatively, since astral sorcery isnt needed for machinery, you can make a mekanism digital miner and cheese any sort of mining you. Astral Sorcery is a mod created by HellFirePvP. ago. More profitable use of your starlight IMO is to create crystal clusters (crystal + liquid starlight + Starmetal dust) - once this grows and sparkles it will yield 1-2 dust and a newly RNG'd celestial crystal. It can be created on the Luminous Crafting Table and higher, during times where the altar has a sufficient amount of starlight. The lower the Rock Crystal's qualities,the poorer it will perform. Possible Solution Steps to Reproduce (for bugs) Have a refined storage system. bak one to not have . The whole structure is made of the following materials: 1 Water Bucket 1 Sea Lantern 1. It is used to acquire Celestial Crystals as well as Stardust once it has fully grown. Guia y todo lo relacionado con el mod astral sorcery. I've tried using both attuned rock crystals and celestial crystals, neither seem to make a difference. Right-clicking on one of the aforementioned blocks with the Linking Tool will display a "Selected <block>!" message in the chat log. MintPolo • 4 yr. And I can confirm, I've left crystals on the ground for hours and they don't despawn. So while a stable loop of starlight and it's associated materials is the end goal, don't forget that Sevtech is actually a lot more forgiving on this than vanilla Astral Sorcery or some other packs. ' If that is the purity stat, how does one uncover it? •Rock Crystals•-If you have followed along with this series of blogs, Rock Crystal and Celestial Crystals have an important use on almost every crafting recipe through the mod of Astral Sorcery. Some of the new tech includes tinkering, exploration and astral sorcery mod. Some of the new tech includes tinkering, exploration and astral sorcery mod. The lower the Rock Crystal's qualities,the poorer it will perform. MintPolo • 4 yr. This unlocks various crafting recipes that are not normally. Astral Sorcery; Chapter 4: “Iridescent heights”. Whenever you’re ampere fan of Thor in Norse mythology, you’ll take one go from playing Astral. They are created by throwing stardust and a rock crystal into a pool. It is used to craft Crystal tools and collect Liquid Starlight in Lightwells. It'll have <uuid>. This is the weirdest issue I've ever had in Minecraft! 1 / 2. To do that you need a linking tool, and a Collector Crystal. So, expect a massive change of gameplay if you’re planning to manufacture a fresh start on Astral Sorcery. Crystal doesn't get inserted. Throw a Rock Crystal + Starmetal Dust into a Sourceblock of Liquid Starlight. Read the Journal/Astral Tome for details. The Celestial Collector Crystal is a block added by Astral Sorcery. To be clear, that recipe requires a Rock or Celestial crystal attuned to Octans. there are suppose to look like crystal shards but in my game they are just white rectangles. In this tutorial we will go through the "Attunement" section of Astral Sorcery. Once a player has reached tier 3 crafting they're able to craft their own Floating Crystals using the Altar. e. Today we work through Environmental Tech and try to get Rock Crystals to get into Astral Sorcery. 11 comments. That's part of why it's a waste of time to try and split Rock Crystals instead of Celestial Crystals: because you're going to be constantly using the excess trash crystals. 1 () Flare is a passive entity from Astral Sorcery. Recipe [] Starmetal Ore is created by exposing Iron Ore to the starlight collected by a Collector Crystal or Celestial Collector Crystal. First, It seems like previous commenters have pointed out the marble issue. Trying to grow a max size Celestial Crystal in Liquid Starlight has a 1 in 6 chance to split a. I also don't have the recipe in the Astral Tome. World Generation & Items. From cave man to the Space Race, hidden ores and hi. You could take an ender chest with you connected to another that is imported in the rock crystal subnet. The fosic resonator ain't working. 現在わ. The Rock Crystal is an item added by Astral Sorcery. • 5 yr. In this tutorial series I will be highlighting some of the more difficult aspects of the game, instead of just showing everything. Diamond Pickaxe required to mine. The sections of the tome can be navigated by scrolling and dragging within the GUI, and individual topics can be accessed by clicking. Also, you should be duplicating celestial crystals instead of rock crystals, there's no advantage to. Yep, that would be the AE crystals that have it on the tooltip. The size and cutting are linked and used mainly in the crafting of rock crystal tools and weapons. ago. Keep dunking crystals into liquid starlight until they split, and the one that splits off will be a higher purity than the one you made it from. The four options are. Transform Rock Crystals into Celestial Crystals by in world crafting. Instead of dipping crystal in starlight fo get size, putting it on a grindstone for cutting and splitting crystal for purity. You gotta keep replacing the starlight. In 1. It is used to infuse various items with Starlight to transform them (such as turning Aquamarines into Resonating Gems) and turning Crystal tools into their infused counterparts. As per some random person on the AS Discord, no. The purity. 4 comments. Spectrekillol. Had Sharpness VII on them so they were at 17. Delete the <uuid>. It can be acquired by mining Rock Crystal Ore. . The Celestial Crystal Cluster is a block added by Astral Sorcery. I'm not sure how the statistics apply to the various things that can be built with Astral Sorcery. For Sevtech you should always always always consult the quest book (well, the Advancements screen lol) before consulting online resources - Sevtech completely reworks how a lot of core mod concepts work, especially in Astral Sorcery. The Rock Crystal is an item added by Astral Sorcery. Should just soak them in liquid starlight, the size will increase every time it consumes the liquid source bock and once it hits max size (400 for rock, 900 for celestial) it has a 1/6 chance to split into two crystals everyone it consumes the liquid, one of the new crystals will have a higher purity. It is only able to hold 2 Buckets' worth of Liquid Starlight. Lenses are single block structures that are used to redirect or extend beams of starlight from Collector Crystals. They are created by throwing stardust and a rock crystal into a pool of liquid starlight where a Celestial Crystal cluster will form. Cyclic has a couple of Item Repairers which can repair most items, that would be trying. Perhaps im doing something wrong still? Or I dont know what I'm doing in general lol. It is found at extremely low altitudes, typically in a y-coordinate range of 1 to 6. If it is placed within 16 blocks of another Celestial Collector Crystal or. You can have up to 10 traits on a crystal, with higher levels counting for multiple (size. This power for clairvoyance is due no less to the rock crystal’s ability to amplify magic. #MischiefOfMice #BitByBit #AstralSorceryThis mod is renewed from older versions! What is it? It allows you to progress through several magical astronomical i. This pack focuses on providing the player a long t. Feed The Beast Wiki. . I constructed a Prism Lens with a rock. Have the entangloporter export power from your base and import items. Pick up both crystals and repeat process with the higher purity crystal. used to customize rock crystals, celestial crystals and mantle stars, as well as to charming through the table of stellar refraction. There are currently 16 constellations available. After about a minute, it will consume the starlight and grow. e. Option 1: Keep using star dust to randomize until getting high purity crystal. Resolution: Not a bug. 0-alphaShaders: to the P. Each. 2) versions of Astral Sorcery, yes. 1. The Luminous Crafting Table is a block added by Astral Sorcery. ago. And I can confirm, I've left crystals on the ground for hours and they don't despawn. From cave man to the. It is used to craft Crystal tools and. When fracturing was first introduced, I had the same questions, so I poked around in the source code. Lightwellは特にRock Crystalの性能に依存しない…はず. 8 and our Size/Shape VI Crystal Swords reduced their damage to only around 6. The Celestial Crystal Cluster is a block added by Astral Sorcery. 12. SevPack is a 1. When placed below the night sky without any obstructions, it will create transparent Illumination Powder blocks in a wide area below it. まず、次の時代であるIV時代の筐体金属、【Tungsten】の入手方法ですが、Astral Sorceryの介入により現時点でも入手出来るようになっているエンドストーン. It can be crafted from a Rock Crystal that is attuned to any of the twelve bright or dim Constellations. Below one of its 4 pillars is a Chest containing loot. Print. I see Astral Sorcery talking about Rock Crystals having purity, but I do not see purity anywhere on the rock crystals. One will be the the original crystal with the original purity and the second will be at a higher purity. When they're dropped into the starlight by a non-player (Tested with World Item Exporter (Integrated Tunnels), Item Dropper (Openblocks), Dropper and Dispenser(vanilla), ) OR when a correctly-dropped crystal splits, as per normal Astral Sorcery mechanics, the items despawn after the usual 5 minutes. 6 with similar stats. Liquid starlight automatically flows from the lightwells to. Right-clicking while outdoors during nighttime displays a view of the night sky's stars, among which the stars of constellations stand out. The cluster will emit particle effects once it has fully grown. FYI the crystal is exposed to the stars, so I do not know. Rock Crystals can hold a total of up to 7 tiers (attributes). Repeat for each ore. It is recommended you get at least a Fortune III pickaxe (there are methods to get Fortune IV, V, and VI on a pickaxe using the refraction table) as it will reduce the number of ores you need to find in the future. Get the Astral Tome + Resonating Wand. This chapter introduces the player to the basic items and blocks they will need throughout Astral Sorcery, which. The tradeoff, in addition to the risk of losing a bucket during infusion and the time. The star factory mod pack is also a great way to learn if you don’t want to watch videos. . VT-14. However I can't for the life of me figure out how to get it all working. The tradeoff, in addition to the risk of losing a bucket during infusion and the time. When it's at max growth you can simply pick it up with another ranged collector filtered on nbt. Would also suggest Direwolf20 1. Rock crystals can be found near bedrock in that spot. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Resources. i am currently playing astral sorcery for the first time and i noticed that the rock crystals ( those thins you find with resonator wand ) look really weird. Figured it out. Can't find Rock Crystal Ore : r/feedthebeast. They are able to be used for all purposes besides attuning the players. The Celestial Collector Crystal is a block added by Astral Sorcery. So, expect a massively alteration of gameplay if you’re planning until make a fresh start on Astral Scrying. It is fairly deep down. 32). 祭壇の強化にはAstral Sorceryの鉱石【Rock Crystal】が必要です。 この鉱石は今までの鉱脈とは異なり鉱脈を示す花などは存在しておらず、夜間【Resonating Wand】を手に持ち、白く光輝く場所の地下を掘り進めることで発見できます。 It doesn't matter what the original rock crystal was before you turn it into an astral crystal. Clear rock crystal quartz is found in the U. As for the crystals, I've forgotten about one for 30 or so minutes while mining and it was still there. 12? Or is this backporting? EDIT: Read the page again, it's the mod version 1. Rock Crystals are important for Astral Sorcery progression. 2) or something but its kinda weirdAstral Enchantment tenders a cluster of happy in to Overworld, letting you explore both sky the sanding to meet ruins, new minerals, and new elements. How do you get liquid starlight? Put the Lightwell down under an open sky, then right-click the Lightwell with a valid item in hand to create Liquid Starlight. Astral Sorcery Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. 8 and our Size/Shape VI Crystal Swords reduced their damage to only around 6. You're already at 110ish, you said, so it's probably not worth moving up from there unless you're REALLY close. Yep, that would be the AE crystals that have it on the tooltip. It is a magic-themed mod based on constellations and star power, which means that most of the mod's content is accessed at nighttime. ATM3 Rock Crystals So me and some friends have been playing All The Mods 3 for the last few days and haven't been able to find any rock crystals for astral sorcery. This one you can do without moving anything. Then hold the wand in either hand. Floating crystals are extremely important for Astral Sorcery and is how to begin your journey. Attuned Celestial Crystals give the most liquid starlight by far, and turning a Celestial Crystal into an Attuned Celestial Crystal is free, but you first need to reach the stage of Astral Sorcery where you can attune things, which is functionally Astral Sorcery Endgame. Make sure the Crystal has a clear view to the sky. The Horologium mantle is exceptionally powerful, as it is one of the only items capable of stopping time and the in game tick rate for all non player. However, it has 4 extra input slots that can be used for more crafting. It's just a different approach to interacting with Astral Sorcery. Does grinding a rock crystal increase the cutting stat, and is that useful for anything beyond making the tools?. That would be the first 5 you pick up. 21 votes, 15 comments.